Pension vs Mortgage Overpayment Calculator
Should extra cash go to pension or mortgage?
Compare the long-term benefit of extra pension contributions against mortgage overpayments for the same monthly amount. Instant result, no signup.
What this tool does
Enter monthly extra cash, horizon, pension net return, and mortgage rate. The tool compares the end values of each route.
Enter Values
Formula Used
Spotted something off?
Calculations, display, or translation — let us know.
Disclaimer
Results are estimates for educational purposes only. They do not constitute financial advice. Consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.
Spare cash faces a binary: pour it into the pension, or overpay the mortgage. Pension wins when net return exceeds mortgage rate, and tax relief on contributions supercharges that. Mortgage overpayment wins when the mortgage rate beats expected pension net return or when you value certain debt reduction over uncertain market returns. 200/month for 25 years at 7% pension return ends at 162,000; applied to a 5% mortgage it saves 105,000 in interest — pension wins in this case.
A worked example
Try the defaults: monthly extra cash of 200, horizon of 25, pension net return of 7%, mortgage rate of 5%. The tool returns 42,912.40. You can adjust any input and the result updates as you type — no submit button, no reload. That's the real power here: seeing how sensitive the output is to one or two assumptions.
What moves the number most
The result responds to Monthly Extra Cash, Horizon, Pension Net Return, and Mortgage Rate. Two inputs usually tip the answer one way or the other. Identify which ones matter most by flipping each value past a round threshold and watching whether the winning option changes.
The formula behind this
Future value of monthly annuity for pension side. Future value at mortgage rate for overpayment side (equivalent to interest saved compounding at mortgage rate). Ignores tax relief on pension — which would increase pension advantage. Everything the calculator does is shown in the formula box below, so you can check the math against your own spreadsheet if you want.
Turning the result into a plan
A projection is just a starting point. The real work is setting the monthly amount aside automatically so the saving happens before you can spend it. Most people who hit savings goals set up a standing order on payday; most who miss them rely on willpower at month-end.
What this doesn't capture
The calculation assumes a steady savings rate and a stable interest rate. Real saving journeys include emergencies, windfalls, and rate changes — especially in easy-access products. The figure is a direction of travel, not a guarantee.
Pension vs overpayment produces a winner based on the inputs provided.
Inputs
This example uses typical values for illustration. Adjust the inputs above to match a specific situation and see how the result changes.
Sources & Methodology
Methodology
Future value of monthly annuity for pension side. Future value at mortgage rate for overpayment side (equivalent to interest saved compounding at mortgage rate). Ignores tax relief on pension — which would increase pension advantage.
References
Frequently Asked Questions
Doesn't tax relief change this?
What about pension access age?
Certain vs uncertain?
Employer pension match?
Related Calculators
Pension Calculator
Project pension pot at retirement from current balance, contributions, and investment growth. Enter pension balance and see the result instantly.
Mortgage Overpayment Calculator
Calculate interest saved and months cut from regular mortgage overpayments above standard payment. Enter mortgage principal and see the result instantly.
Save vs Pay Off Debt Calculator
Compare expected savings growth against interest saved by paying off debt to decide which option wins. Enter extra cash and see the result instantly.
More Savings Calculators
Savings
1000-Day Savings Challenge Calculator
Calculate total savings from a 1000-day challenge that saves an increasing amount each day. Enter starting daily amount to see total saved across 1000 days.
Savings
Annual Savings Growth Calculator
Calculate year-over-year savings growth rate from current and prior balance. Enter last year's savings and see the result instantly.
Savings
Bucket Retirement Strategy Calculator
Allocate retirement savings across three buckets — immediate cash, medium-term income, and long-term growth. Enter retirement pot to see each bucket's amount.
Savings
Bucket Strategy Calculator
Split a portfolio into near-term cash, medium-term bonds, and long-term growth buckets based on target allocations. Educational tool, no signup required.
Savings
Cash vs Invest Calculator
Compare long-term value of holding cash vs investing the same amount at expected market returns. Enter cash rate and investment return to see opportunity cost.
Savings
Catch-Up Savings Calculator
Work out the monthly contribution needed to reach a savings goal given what you already have, years remaining, and an expected return rate.
Explore Other Financial Tools
Mortgage
Mortgage Calculator
Estimate monthly mortgage payments based on loan amount, interest rate, and amortization period. Calculate total interest paid over loan term.
Investing
Perpetuity Value Calculator
Calculate the present value of a perpetuity — infinite annual cash flow at a discount rate. Free educational calculator with the math explained step by step.
Income
Pay Rise Calculator
Calculate net annual, monthly, and weekly increase from a percentage pay rise after tax. Enter annual salary and pay rise percentage for an instant result.